Instructions for reviewers: Please assess the article that you have received in the terms provided on this sheet. If you feel that you cannot provide such commentary in our peer review, please return the essay to us to be sent out to a different scholar.
Please clearly indicate your answer to these questions, and edit the fields below to provide commentary where requested.
1) In the estimation of the reviewer, this article is:
a) Ready for Publication
b) In Need of Minimal Editing or Revision (provide comments below)
c) In Need of Substantial Editing or Revision (provide comments below)
In the case of answer (b) or (c), please outline the necessary revisions here:
2) In your estimation what is the most significant contribution that this essay makes to the study of the Balkans?
3) Did you find the central argument of the essay convincing? Do you have any feedback concerning the evidence, support, or flow of this argument?
4) Please use this field to provide any further commentary to the author.